LV5 Real Estate Team
Real Estate Team
at Hartsock Realty · Ohio
Closed

5051-5095 MIRROR LAKE DRIVE

Lima, OH 45801

$350,000

MLS #307612

Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
1
Type
Single Family Home
Year Built
1931

About this home

STEP BACK IN TIME ON THIS EXTRAORDINARY, HISTORIC RETREAT IN BATH TWP., ORIGINALLY BUILT BY NOTED, LOCAL ENTREPRENEUR, T.R. SCHOONOVER IN 1931. RICH IN CHARACTER & FULL OF TIMELESS CHARM, THIS ONE-OF-A-KIND PROPERTY FEATURES THE SERENE & REFLECTIVE MIRROR LAKE AS ITS CENTERPIECE--AN IDEAL SETTING FOR PEACEFUL MOMENTS OR UNFORGETTABLE GATHERINGS. AT THE HEART OF THE PROPERTY, STANDS THE ORIGINAL LODGE/CLUBHOUSE WITH ITS METAL/COPPER ROOF & FEATURING A SPECTACULAR, STONE FIREPLACE, A SPACIOUS 26X36 DINING AREA & 10X28 KITCHEN--JUST PERFECT FOR HOSTING EVENTS OR GET TOGETHERS OR SIMPLY ENJOYING LAKESIDE MEALS. IMAGINE IF THESE KNOTTY PINE WALLS COULD TALK?!!--SO MUCH HISTORY! ADDITIONAL AMENITIES INCLUDE RESTROOMS, BATHHOUSE, AND AN OUTBUILDING EQUIPPED WITH STABLES. HISTORY ENTHUSIASTS WILL TRULY APPRECIATE THE RECLAIMED FOUNTAIN FROM THE CHICAGO WORLD'S FAIR--ADDING A RARE & MEANINGFUL TOUCH TO THE SPACIOUS GROUNDS. COMPLETING THE PROPERTY IS THE ORIGINAL CARETAKER'S, 3BR/1BTH, RANCH STYLE HOME. ONLY 884 SQ.FT. OF LIVING AREA, BUT THIS HOME IS BRIMMING WITH POTENTIAL AMIDST THE BEAUTY AND TRANQUILTY OF THIS UNIQUE PROPERTY. WHETHER IN SEARCH OF A PRIVATE SANCTUARY, NATURE INSPIRED VENUE, OR A PIECE OF LOCAL HISTORY, THIS EXCEPTIONAL PROPERTY OFFERS LIMITLESS POSSIBLILITIES. THIS ONE WON'T LAST!!!!!

Property details

Lot size
7 acres
Listed
5/21/2026
Listing office
Ron Spencer Real Estate
Listing agent
Randall Faulder
ZIP
45801
Status
Closed

Mortgage calculator

Estimated monthly

$2,381

per month, all-in

Principal & interest
$1,863
Property tax
$408
Insurance
$110
Loan amount: $280,000 · Down: $70,000

Estimates only. Actual payments vary by lender, credit, taxes, insurance, and HOA. Not a loan offer. Contact LV5 for a referral to a trusted local lender.

Location & walkability

Neighborhood walkability coming soon

We're enabling Walk Score® on every listing. In the meantime, the map shows the exact location. Call (419) 302-3940 for detailed neighborhood insight.

Similar homes nearby

Active listings in Lima in a similar price range

Recently sold nearby

Closed comps in Lima